Contrasts for violin, clarinet and piano, Sz. 111, BB 116
I. Verbunkos (Recruiting Dance)
II. Pihenő (Relaxation)
III. Sebes (Fast Dance)
Hungarian-born composer, ethnomusicologist, pianist and teacher Béla Bartók transcended traditional boundaries and embarked on a journey to explore the rich tapestry of folk traditions, melding them seamlessly with his unique compositional voice. Acknowledged as one of the greatest artists of the twentieth century, Bartók contributed to establishing the foundations for the study of comparative musical folklore in Hungary and published several important studies of Hungarian and Romanian folk music.
The impetus to write Contrasts came from Bartok’s compatriot Joseph Szigeti in 1938, who had emigrated to the United States and befriended the ‘King of Swing’, clarinettist Benny Goodman. The idea of writing for a jazz musician did not appeal to Bartók at first, but after meeting with Goodman and familiarising himself with the American’s work, a first draft was written entitled Rhapsody. Cast in the traditional two-movement model, the work was premiered at Carnegie Hall in January 1939 by Szigeti, Goodman and pianist Endre Petri. A year later, during Bartók’s relocation to America, due to his uneasiness about Hungary’s alliance with the Third Reich, the composition returned, but this time Bartók played the piano part and a new slow movement, Pihenő, was inserted between the original first and second sections. It was renamed Contrasts and recorded by the trio under the Columbia Records label in May 1940.
One of the jewels of his chamber music repertoire, the work’s title aptly reflects the piece's dynamic interplay of styles, textures and tonal colours. Contrasts comprises three movements, each a miniature masterpiece in its own right. The first and final movements feature cadenzas to highlight the virtuosity of the clarinet and violin respectively, which prompted a critic for the New York Times to say that Bartók ‘spared neither the fingers nor ears nor lips of the performers’.
The first movement, Verbunkos (Recruiting Dance), evokes the type of dance that was employed by officers of the imperial army who visited Hungarian villages to attract recruits in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. Opening with a captivating clarinet cadenza, its folk-like character draws inspiration from Hungarian dance traditions. As the violin and piano join the conversation, the movement unfolds as a spirited discourse, featuring rhythmic animation and infectious energy.
The second movement, Pihenő (Relaxation), provides a stark contrast to the momentum of Verbunkos. Here, Bartók delves into the realm of nocturnal serenity, with the clarinet and violin engaging in a contemplative interchange of melodic fragments. The piano, often acting as a shimmering backdrop, enhances the dreamlike atmosphere.
The final movement, Sebes (Fast Dance), is a tour de force of virtuosity and rhythmic intricacy. An additional layer of complexity is infused into the score in its requirement of the clarinettist to switch from a clarinet in A to a B flat instrument for the opening and closing sections. The violin must also be returned to G sharp, D and E flat. Drawing inspiration from Eastern European folk dances, this movement bursts forth with relentless energy and intricate polyrhythms. The violin, clarinet and piano participate in a dazzling display of technical prowess, bringing the work to a gripping and exhilarating conclusion.
Contrasts not only showcases Bartók's fascination with folk music and his innate understanding of the genre, but also highlights his inimitable facility to seamlessly integrate diverse influences into a cohesive and compelling musical narrative. The work epitomises the composer's avant-garde vision, blending elements of tradition with a contemporary and exploratory spirit.